Christmas Cookie
101 recipes found
Layered Chocolate Mint Bars
A chocolate mint is a very fine way to end an evening, whether it’s wrapped in shiny foil and dropped with the check or found perched upon a fluffy hotel pillow, waiting patiently for your return from a luxurious dinner. So why not make it the main event? In this large-format version, it shines as a stand-alone dessert — somehow simultaneously rich and refreshing, thanks to an infusion of fresh mint and crème de menthe. The nostalgic flavor combination is evergreen, but it also shouts “holiday!” enthusiastically from the rooftops, satisfying a festive crowd in all its generous glory. Lay this dramatic slab on your table after an indulgent meal and invite your guests to cut slices as they please, revealing elegant contrasting layers. Stash any extra in the freezer for an especially refreshing bite!
Chocolate Cherry Magic Cookie Bars
Magic cookie bars, seven-layer bars and Hello Dolly bars are all variations on a theme: a buttery graham cracker crust topped with sweetened condensed milk, coconut, nuts and semisweet chocolate chips (sometimes with butterscotch chips thrown in, too). This version ups the chocolate factor by adding a bit of cocoa to the crust and lots of bittersweet chocolate to the topping. A sprinkle of dried cherries at the end adds a much-needed punch of bright, tart flavor, making these the perfect afternoon pick-me-up or lunchbox treat. Add a bit of flaky salt to the top to make these extra craveable.
Cookie Butter Blondies
Speculoos cookie butter elevates this otherwise simple recipe for blondies. Packed with brown sugar and browned butter, these cookie bars are rich, caramelly and chewy. Shredded coconut adds a bit of toasty depth that pairs beautifully with the lightly spiced cookie butter, and a generous amount of salt helps these blondies from being cloyingly sweet.
Cinnamon Toast Cookies
Buttery-sweet like cinnamon toast in the snackable size of a crouton, these lovable cookies are quick to make and quicker to eat. Start by coating cubes of white bread in a mixture of melted butter, sugar and cinnamon. For a slightly more grown-up flavor, use a pumpkin-spice blend instead of straight cinnamon. As the cubes bake, the bread toasts and the sugar caramelizes. Then sprinkle with more cinnamon sugar for sparkle and crunch. Enjoy by the handful, over ice cream or in a bowl of milk by the spoonful. Or give them to friends and watch them smile wide, then grab another.
Biscochitos
Even as New Mexico’s official state cookie and an important Christmas tradition in Hispanic and Latin American cultures, biscochitos might not seem to have anything outlandish or fancy about them, at a glance — that is, until you take a bite. Full of dynamic flavor and a delicate texture that is so pleasant to eat, over and over again (they’re hard to resist), these anise-studded, orange-and-vanilla-scented bites are perfect to package as a gift, to leave out for guests to snack on or to serve alongside cajeta ice cream or a rich butterscotch pudding as part of an important holiday meal. You might also try them alongside your favorite celebration drink, like rompope, ponche or a simple hot chocolate.
Ginger Cheesecake Cookies
Three types of ginger — ground, fresh and crystallized — run through these flavorful cookies with a secret. Hidden inside is a creamy cheesecake filling that readily complements and tempers their spicy bite. Skip the crystallized ginger, if you like, but it really makes them pop, as does a finish in brightly colored sanding sugar. If you have only regular white sugar, they’ll still be stunning.
Matcha-Black Sesame Shortbreads
Toasty black sesame and bittersweet matcha come together in this not-too-sweet holiday cookie. The two doughs are pressed and rolled together to make an impressive slice-and-bake shortbread that’s also a cinch to prepare ahead. Make and freeze the logs whenever you like in advance of the holidays, then simply thaw and bake for effortless hosting.
Iced Peppermint Cookies
Flavored with peppermint extract, these zingy shortbread rounds — a visual riff on black and white cookies — have an especially bright, buttery flavor that’s echoed in the icing. The red and white glaze recalls candy canes and Starlight mints, but feel free to play with different colors when decorating these. Or skip the glaze entirely for an easy-to-make minty cookie with a more classic appearance.
Bûche de Noël Cookies
These rolled cookies are inspired by chocolate rugelach but are sliced to look like mini Yule logs. Cacao nibs and coarse sugar finish the outside to give these tender treats a little bit of crunch. A dusting with powdered sugar is optional, but makes them look extra festive, like part of a snowy scene.
Rum-Buttered Almond Cookies
Nutty, buttery and a bit boozy, these festive cookies come together in minutes, making them perfect for holiday baking. (They also happen to be gluten-free.) Reminiscent of the almond flavor and pillowy texture of an Italian pignoli cookie, this recipe calls for brushing them with rum-infused butter twice — once before baking and another round when hot from the oven — which imbues them with even more warmth and richness.
Holiday Rocky Road
Rocky road might be synonymous with ice cream in the United States, but, in Australia and Britain, it’s a fudgelike candy made by stirring any assortment of marshmallows, dried fruit and nuts into melted chocolate. (In Australia, gummy candies also feature.) This recipe relies on the subtle aroma of speculoos cookies, spice drops and pumpkin pie spice to evoke the holidays. You can also use it as a guide to utilize leftovers from gingerbread house decorating: Swap the cookies for broken gingerbread and the marshmallows and gumdrops for any chewy candy.
Lemon-Turmeric Crinkle Cookies
Delivering warmth from turmeric and brightness from lemon zest, these golden crinkled cookies feel (and look) like sunbeams breaking through clouds. Imagine powdered doughnuts run through with Fruit Loops cereal milk on a Saturday morning. In fact, these soft, crisp-edged cookies are lovely for breakfast, but don’t restrict their bright, sunny disposition to a specific time of day: Pair them with a glass of milk or cup of herbal tea, whether as an afternoon pick-me-up or a not-too-sweet finish to any meal.
Stained Glass Cookies
These stunning cookies would be a gorgeous addition to any holiday cookie assortment, and they are not much more difficult than any roll-and-cut cookie. The cookie base is lightly sweetened and tender, thanks to powdered sugar and an extra egg yolk, and the glass-like centers are made from crushed hard candies that melt in the heat of the oven. Use a few different colors of candy for a tie-dye effect or single colors for a bolder look. Feel free to use any shaped cookie cutter you like — just make sure they are large enough that there is space to cut out a good-sized hole in the center. Featured in: Can You Find Awe in Christmas Cookies?
Old-Fashioned Shortbread
The classic cocktail transforms into a cookie here, with bourbon-soaked cherries and candied orange studding buttery shortbread. Balancing that fruity sweetness are sliced almonds, which give the rounds extra crunch and richness. To fully capture the spirit of an old-fashioned, the dough gets a final egg wash with whiskey on top. Keep a log of this slice-and-bake shortbread in the fridge to prepare fresh batches over a couple of days or bake them all at once and save the rest in an airtight container.
Rainbow Rave Cookies
This recipe is adapted from “Start Here: Instructions for Becoming a Better Cook” by Sohla El-Waylly and is originally titled Lisa Frank Cookies. It earns that name by being a big sucker punch of sugary nostalgia. A trio of extracts (pure vanilla, imitation vanilla and almond) is key to giving these cookies the aura of that prepackaged baked good you might’ve tucked into your lunchbox as a kid, but they’re better because you’re making them fresh. Best of all, they come together in a snap, stirred up in one bowl and baked on the same day. You can throw a rainbow rave for your mouth almost instantly.
Gingerbread Blondies
With the chewy texture of the best fudgy brownie and all the festive flavors of your favorite gingerbread cookies, these spicy bars make a bold statement for the holidays. Browning the butter gives them a deep, caramelized flavor, which rounds out the warming brown sugar and fragrant spices. The white chocolate drizzle on top is purely for looks, so feel free to leave it out if you’re short on time. These bars taste just as good without it.
Matcha Latte Cookies
This is a matcha latte in cookie form. Atop the chewy, Grinch-green cookie sits a cloud of ermine icing, an old-fashioned boiled-milk frosting (like the kind you might find in midcentury American baking and grocery-store cupcakes), whose sugared lightness balances out the more intense, bittersweet base. Out of the oven, these cookies might look puffy, but as they cool on their pans, they will continue to cook and deflate, becoming their truest chewiest selves. If you want to skip the frosting, a little powdered sugar is a lovely, snowy finish.
Lemon Butter Curls
Delicate but sturdy, these lemon butter shortbreads are perfect for a casual afternoon treat or relaxed holiday cookie. A combination of butter, egg yolks and a bit of cornstarch ensures a texture that melts in your mouth. Lemon zest adds a bright sparkle, and a light glaze of lemon juice and powdered sugar lends a tart finish. Make these into curls as shown or pipe them into any shape you prefer: Rings, squiggle or pushing the dough through a cookie press can all be fun. You also can roll and shape the dough by hand instead of piping or pressing it.
Mexican Hot Chocolate Cookies
These spiced and spicy cookies, chocolaty and brimming with molten marshmallow, are a terrific treat to keep you warm in the colder months. The dough itself is imbued with cinnamon and a bit of ground cayenne, a combination commonly found in Mexican hot chocolate that also gives these cookies a flavor reminiscent of the holidays — and a slight kick when you least expect it. The marshmallowy interior provides a wonderful chew and maintains a pillowy soft texture, even after a few days in an airtight container. Make sure to freeze the marshmallows fully to give the cookies their hallmark ripple of white peeking through their sparkly chocolate exterior. (Otherwise, the marshmallows will dissolve into the cookies as they bake.)
Technicolor Cookies
Cookies artfully decorated with royal icing are a holiday classic, but their fine details and beautiful colors can take hours to achieve. Not with these gorgeous cookies. Once the icing is made and stained, it takes only a few minutes to decorate. The icing is simply poured over the cookies, a technique inspired by the one used to pour swirly colors of mirror glaze over smooth cakes. (For a quicker alternative to royal icing, simply dip or drizzle the cookies with melted chocolate.) No two cookies will be the same, and that’s a big part of the charm. Underneath the exterior is a crisp, satisfying shortbread flavored with heaps of bright orange zest and quintessential winter spices.
Neapolitan Checkerboard Cookies
This recipe combines the classic flavors of chocolate, strawberry and vanilla — reminiscent of Neapolitan ice cream — all in one bite. While the assembly may seem daunting at first, it can be a fun project, and the end result is graphic and delicious. In making a perfect checkerboard pattern, you’ll inevitably have some scraps. Roll them into a log, which can then be sliced and baked into marbled shortbreads.
Cheddar Chive Crisps
Every cookie tin deserves a little savory bite. These delicate crisps are speckled with fresh herbs and have a golden vein of cheese running through the dough. Fresh ground black pepper adds a gentle, lingering heat. You can go with any firm cheese that has strong notes here; sharp Cheddar, Parmesan or pecorino will all work nicely. Both the dough and cheese will benefit from staying cold while you work, so return the dough to the refrigerator as often as necessary to keep it chilled. (This cookie is one of six cookies that you can make with this Butter Shortbread Dough recipe. If you make that dough, you can make a double batch of the Cheddar Chive Crisps or try any of the other five recipes.)
Orange, Pistachio and Chocolate Shortbread
This buttery shortbread showcases the classic combination of candied orange and dark chocolate. The cookie ages very nicely and is even better in the days after it is baked. The cookie dough will feel crumbly when it’s removed from the mixing bowl but pressing the dough into the baking pan and allowing the dough to hydrate over the course of a few hours will help it come together.
Pecan Linzer Bars
These bars have the nutty and jammy vibes of a classic Linzer torte, the Austrian dessert of almond or hazelnut shortbread layered with preserves. The buttery dough bakes up tender, but it can be difficult to roll out. Here, we’re using the same components in a simplified way: pressing in the crust, crumbling over the topping and baking in a brownie pan before cutting into bars. You can use any nut and preserve combination, but the traditional filling of raspberry jam or red currant jelly offers a nice hit of acidity to contrast the sweet cookie crust.