Thumbprint Cookies

2 recipes found

This PB&J Cookie Is Everything You Loved About Being a Kid
www.seriouseats.com faviconSerious Eats
Aug 8, 2025

This PB&J Cookie Is Everything You Loved About Being a Kid

Occupying the space between a classic thumbprint cookie and a peanut butter blossom, these peanut butter and jelly thumbprint cookies are a light, just-sweet-enough treat.

44m12,24 cookies
Your Favorite Sandwich, Now a Buttery, Crumbly, Oven-Fresh Cookie
www.seriouseats.com faviconSerious Eats
Jul 8, 2025

Your Favorite Sandwich, Now a Buttery, Crumbly, Oven-Fresh Cookie

Occupying the space between a classic thumbprint cookie and a peanut butter blossom, these peanut butter and jelly thumbprint cookies are a light, just-sweet-enough treat.

44m12,24 cookies